Cases9 cases

4 to 8 of 9

1. IL-0178 On EKS, HPA scale-in returned 502 errors because containers stopped before their pod IPs left the Service endpoints, and after blue/green switches conntrack kept sending established connections to deleted pods behind an instance-mode ALB

   Lotte E-commerce2022

   Symptoms

   LOTTE ON, Lotte E-commerce's online shopping mall of about 40 microservices on Amazon EKS, returned errors for a period of time whenever the Horizontal Pod Autoscaler (HPA) scaled pods in after load dropped. Requests reached containers that had already been deleted and failed with 502 errors.

   High error rateIntermittent timeoutsStale endpoint routing

   Trigger

   HPA scale-in deleting pods, and the deletion of Blue pods after a blue/green switch of the Service label selector.

   Root cause

   DNS or network fault

   Component

   Horizontal pod autoscalerPod terminationkube-proxyconntrack tableCloud load balancerIngress controller

   Contributing factor

   Unreviewed defaults

   Remediation

   • delayed container shutdown on pod deletion (a wait in the SIGTERM handler or a preStop sleep, capped by terminationGracePeriodSeconds) so containers stop only after the pod has left the Service endpoints
   • switched some workloads' Ingress-created ALBs from instance mode to IP mode so traffic goes straight to pod IPs without iptables and conntrack

   Action items

   • Move all workloads to ALB IP mode gradually

   Lessons

   Removing a pod from Service endpoints and stopping its containers happen at the same time in Kubernetes, so a pod can stop while traffic is still routed to it unless shutdown is delayed with a preStop hook or in the application. With an instance-mode ALB, traffic passes through node iptables and conntrack, and established connections can keep going to a pod IP after its iptables rules are gone. IP mode avoids that path, within the limit of 1000 targets per target group.

   View case
2. IL-0199 A non-essential container exceeding its memory limit made GitHub's production pods unavailable, and their restarts failed because a DNS maintenance change had left the clusters unable to reach the image registry

   GitHub2020

   Symptoms

   At 08:18 UTC on 13 July 2020, production Kubernetes pods began to be marked unavailable. The loss of pods spread through the clusters and reduced capacity until GitHub.com services went down.

   OOMKilledImage pull failuresService outage

   Trigger

   A container in the production pods exceeded its memory limit and was terminated; a routine DNS maintenance operation completed earlier had left the clusters unable to reach the image registry.

   Root cause

   DNS or network fault

   Component

   Container memory limitContainer registry and its credentials

   Contributing factor

   Overlapping failuresHarmful manual actionSingle point of failure

   Remediation

   • restarted the process with the cached DNS records so the clusters could reach the registry
   • fetched the container images, redeployed and recovered the services

   Action items

   • Improve monitoring so pod restarts cannot fail again in the same pattern
   • Minimise the dependency on the image registry
   • Expand validation during DNS changes
   • Re-evaluate all existing Kubernetes deployment policies
   • Improve progressive deployments so the impact of a deployment can be evaluated incrementally

   Lessons

   A container that production traffic does not need can still take pods out of service, because a pod is available only when all of its containers are healthy. ImagePullPolicy Always turns every container restart into a registry dependency, so an unrelated DNS change that breaks registry access turns a one-minute self-healing event into a long outage, and a mass redeploy spreads it.

   View case
3. IL-0056 Calls from EKS pods to services behind an NLB in another VPC failed intermittently because the AWS VPC CNI did source NAT on the node

   MindTickle2020

   Symptoms

   On the Saturday the production cluster was moved from kops to EKS, the platform became very slow and too unstable to keep running, and the team reverted.

   Intermittent connection failuresHigh latency

   Trigger

   Production was moved from a kops cluster using Weave networking to a new EKS cluster using the AWS VPC CNI, without external SNAT enabled.

   Root cause

   DNS or network fault

   Component

   AWS VPC CNI

   Contributing factor

   Unreviewed defaultsUnverified assumption

   Detection

   The team lead saw the platform behaving very slowly after the switch to EKS and phoned the author.

   Remediation

   • reverted production to the kops cluster
   • set AWS_VPC_K8S_CNI_EXTERNALSNAT=true in the AWS VPC CNI

   Action items

   • Monitor and alert on the AWS VPC CNI

   Lessons

   In a networking problem every component in the stack is a suspect; ruling out EKS early cost a lot of time. A DaemonSet that pinged every component from every other one exposed the anomaly that led to the fix. The team had only skimmed the AWS CNI documentation before the migration; knowing how the plugin works internally would have led to better judgements and hypotheses while debugging.

   View case
4. IL-0049 Partial DNS outage after CoreDNS scaled down and kube-proxy failed to delete stale conntrack entries

   Preply2020

   Symptoms

   Prometheus detected a high rate of 5xx responses on three services, called A, B and C in the write-up, and paged the on-call engineers through VictorOps at 22:18 EET. The 5xx rate was also visible in Kibana.

   DNS resolution failuresHigh error rateStale endpoint routing

   Trigger

   Because load in the cluster was low, the CoreDNS autoscaler reduced the number of CoreDNS pods from 3 to 2.

   Root cause

   DNS or network fault

   Component

   CoreDNSkube-proxyconntrack table

   Contributing factor

   Automation amplificationIgnored early signalNo caching

   Detection

   Prometheus alerted on a high 5xx rate on services A, B and C and paged on-call through VictorOps.

   Remediation

   • reverted the latest release of the affected service
   • a regular deploy created new nodes, the CoreDNS autoscaler added CoreDNS pods, and the conntrack table was rewritten

   Action items

   • Disable the autoscaler for CoreDNS
   • Run a DNS cache server in production
   • Monitor conntrack usage

   Lessons

   Scaling CoreDNS down is not free: if kube-proxy fails to clear conntrack entries for the removed pod, clients keep sending DNS queries to it. Known DNS weaknesses in a cluster should be prioritised before they cause an outage, and fixes that only treat consequences leave the underlying conntrack problem in place.

   View case
5. IL-0057 Higher p99 latency after moving a reverse proxy to EKS, from outgoing connections delayed by a SNAT conntrack race

   Prezi2019

   Symptoms

   Prometheus alerts fired on tail latency: from 7/24, the p99 response time of a few services went up after Prezi moved its Nginx-based reverse proxy, smartgateway, from dedicated Elastic Beanstalk machines onto shared Kubernetes worker nodes. The bump affected only the tail, so the earlier monitoring of average response times would most certainly have missed it.

   High latencyIntermittent timeouts

   Trigger

   Moving the reverse proxy onto shared EKS worker nodes, where its outgoing connections went through source NAT on the node and some SYN packets were dropped by a race in Netfilter's conntrack.

   Root cause

   DNS or network fault

   Component

   conntrack tableAWS VPC CNILinux kernelNode operating system image

   Contributing factor

   Unreviewed defaultsUnpatched known bug

   Detection

   Prometheus alerts on p99 latency fired after the reverse proxy migration.

   Remediation

   • added AWS X-Ray tracing and an $upstream_connect_time trace attribute to locate the delay
   • ran more pods of the service on more nodes, which reduced but did not end the delays
   • set AWS_VPC_K8S_CNI_EXTERNALSNAT=true on the AWS VPC CNI to turn off SNAT on the nodes

   Lessons

   Alerting on tail latency instead of averages caught a problem that would otherwise have gone unnoticed, and tracing turned a vague slowdown into a measured connect delay. Delays of exactly 1 or 3 seconds on new outgoing connections point to dropped SYN packets, and on EKS the SNAT done by the VPC CNI is where to look.

   View case

By root cause1