Cases2 cases

1 to 2 of 2

1. IL-0250 slack.com stopped resolving on some DNSSEC-validating resolvers for about 24 hours after DNSSEC signing was turned on

   Slack2021

   Symptoms

   Soon after Slack published the DS record for slack.com at its DNS registrar on 30 September 2021, the Customer Experience team started getting user reports of "ERR_NAME_NOT_RESOLVED" errors in Slack clients. Fewer than 1% of online users were affected, and most reports came from users of one private corporate recursive resolver and of Google Public DNS (8.8.8.8).

   DNS resolution failures

   Trigger

   On 30 September 2021 the Traffic Engineering team enabled DNSSEC signing on the slack.com zone in Amazon Route 53 and on its sub-delegated zones in NS1, and after a three-hour soak published the slack.com DS record at the DNS registrar.

   Root cause

   Software defect

   Component

   Authoritative DNS servers and recordsRecursive DNS resolver serviceTerraform

   Contributing factor

   Unrepresentative stagingUnverified assumptionHarmful manual actionIneffective rollbackLimited debug access

   Detection

   Customer Experience received user reports of "ERR_NAME_NOT_RESOLVED" errors in Slack clients, and customers sent NetLog captures through support cases. After signing was rolled back, Slack's external DNS and DNSSEC resolution probes alerted the Traffic team.

   Remediation

   • Removed the slack.com DS record from the DNS registrar
   • Rolled back DNSSEC signing on the slack.com authoritative and delegated zones, which made resolution worse
   • Asked major ISPs and public DNS resolver operators to flush their cached slack.com records
   • Flushed the slack.com records on Google's 8.8.8.8 and Cloudflare's 1.1.1.1 through their public flush sites

   Lessons

   The DNSSEC rollout had been tested only on domains without a wildcard record, so the Route 53 wildcard NSEC bug first appeared on slack.com; Slack names not testing a wildcard domain first as an oversight. Removing the DS record at the registrar does not stop validation at once, because resolvers cache the DS record from the .com zone for up to 24 hours, and removing the DNSKEY while that record is still cached makes every validating resolver fail. Managing DNS through Terraform hid the console warning about disabling DNSSEC. Re-enabling signing would neither have helped nor hurt, because Route 53 generates a new ZSK each time signing is enabled.

   View case
2. IL-0229 bunny.net's DNS servers crashed in a loop on a corrupted routing database file and could not fetch a fix from its CDN

   bunny.net2021

   Symptoms

   On 22 June 2021, within minutes of an update released at 8:25 AM UTC, bunny.net's global fleet of close to 100 DNS servers kept crashing and restarting, more than 60% of traffic was lost, hundreds of Gbits of throughput disappeared, and over 750,000 websites were affected. After 10 minutes the team realised that the DNS servers were restarting and dying and that nothing could bring them back up in that state.

   Container crash loopDNS resolution failuresService outageMisrouted requestsLoad imbalance

   Trigger

   At 8:25 AM UTC bunny.net released an update meant to reduce the download size of the SmartEdge optimization database, and it uploaded a corrupted file to Edge Storage.

   Root cause

   Faulty deployment

   Component

   Authoritative DNS servers and recordsCDN and edge networkObject storage

   Contributing factor

   Circular dependencySingle point of failureAutomation amplificationIneffective rollbackHarmful manual action

   Detection

   About 10 minutes after the release, the team realised that the DNS servers were restarting and dying.

   Remediation

   • Deployed by hand an update that disabled the SmartEdge system on the DNS nodes
   • Routed all requests through Frankfurt instead of Madrid on a couple of DNS servers
   • Migrated the deployment systems and files to a third-party cloud storage service
   • Rewired the deployment system and DNS software to the new storage and deployed
   • Synced the databases and deployed the newest file sets through the third-party service

   Action items

   • Phase out the BinaryPack library as a hot-fix
   • Test third-party libraries more extensively
   • Migrate the internal APIs to an independent third-party service
   • Find how to stop non-critical software from becoming a single point of failure across clusters
   • Make the DNS system keep a local copy of all backup data with automatic failure detection

   Lessons

   bunny.net had built its systems to rely on each other, including the critical parts of its internal infrastructure, so one corrupted file brought down several layers of redundancy with no way back. A part of the infrastructure treated as non-critical turned out to be a single point of failure for several clusters at once, which canary deployments did not catch. Building infrastructure inside its own ecosystem lets one failure cascade through all of it. In the rush to fix the outage the team made typos and mistakes, and the final deployment came after it calmed down and double-checked everything.

   View case

By root cause2