Cases3 cases

1 to 3 of 3

1. IL-0437 Old pods from an unfinished Argo Rollouts canary could not start with a Helm-updated ConfigMap and died in a cascade

   Gunosy2023

   Symptoms

   During a traffic surge from a breaking news alert, pods of a Gunosy service on Kubernetes could not start because the containers could not read their settings from the ConfigMap. The pods that kept running took the extra load and were restarted, failed to start again, and pod after pod died.

   Container crash loop

   Trigger

   A breaking news alert increased traffic and pods were scaled out automatically while a release that removed an old database's settings from the ConfigMap had been rolled out to only one canary pod.

   Root cause

   Faulty deployment

   Component

   ConfigMaps and SecretsHelmProgressive delivery controller

   Contributing factor

   Partial rolloutAutomation amplification

   Action items

   • Configure Argo Rollouts to roll out automatically, with setWeight 1, a one-hour pause and then setWeight 100
   • Add the "helm.sh/resource-policy": keep annotation so Helm keeps past versions of the ConfigMap
   • Build and use a Helm plugin, helm-clear, that keeps only the last few ConfigMap versions by the revision number in their names, set to keep 5 in CD

   Lessons

   Gunosy holds that a review that only resolves to be careful next time would soon be followed by the same failure, because human attention cannot be relied on, so each incident gets a permanent fix built into the system. Keeping past ConfigMap versions also made it possible to roll back quickly without going through CI/CD, which a ConfigMap change had previously prevented.

   View case
2. IL-0229 bunny.net's DNS servers crashed in a loop on a corrupted routing database file and could not fetch a fix from its CDN

   bunny.net2021

   Symptoms

   On 22 June 2021, within minutes of an update released at 8:25 AM UTC, bunny.net's global fleet of close to 100 DNS servers kept crashing and restarting, more than 60% of traffic was lost, hundreds of Gbits of throughput disappeared, and over 750,000 websites were affected. After 10 minutes the team realised that the DNS servers were restarting and dying and that nothing could bring them back up in that state.

   Container crash loopDNS resolution failuresService outageMisrouted requestsLoad imbalance

   Trigger

   At 8:25 AM UTC bunny.net released an update meant to reduce the download size of the SmartEdge optimization database, and it uploaded a corrupted file to Edge Storage.

   Root cause

   Faulty deployment

   Component

   Authoritative DNS servers and recordsCDN and edge networkObject storage

   Contributing factor

   Circular dependencySingle point of failureAutomation amplificationIneffective rollbackHarmful manual action

   Detection

   About 10 minutes after the release, the team realised that the DNS servers were restarting and dying.

   Remediation

   • Deployed by hand an update that disabled the SmartEdge system on the DNS nodes
   • Routed all requests through Frankfurt instead of Madrid on a couple of DNS servers
   • Migrated the deployment systems and files to a third-party cloud storage service
   • Rewired the deployment system and DNS software to the new storage and deployed
   • Synced the databases and deployed the newest file sets through the third-party service

   Action items

   • Phase out the BinaryPack library as a hot-fix
   • Test third-party libraries more extensively
   • Migrate the internal APIs to an independent third-party service
   • Find how to stop non-critical software from becoming a single point of failure across clusters
   • Make the DNS system keep a local copy of all backup data with automatic failure detection

   Lessons

   bunny.net had built its systems to rely on each other, including the critical parts of its internal infrastructure, so one corrupted file brought down several layers of redundancy with no way back. A part of the infrastructure treated as non-critical turned out to be a single point of failure for several clusters at once, which canary deployments did not catch. Building infrastructure inside its own ecosystem lets one failure cascade through all of it. In the rush to fix the outage the team made typos and mistakes, and the final deployment came after it calmed down and double-checked everything.

   View case
3. IL-0467 Boskos crash-looped after a node drain started it from a buggy StatefulSet image, failing Kubernetes PR jobs for 9 hours

   Kubernetes project2019

   Symptoms

   Overnight into 26 March 2019 (PDT), every Prow test job that needed a GCP project from Boskos, the Kubernetes test-infra service that hands out GCP projects to test jobs, failed. The required job pull-kubernetes-e2e-gce failed on every run, so no pull request could be merged in kubernetes/kubernetes for just over nine hours, and other projects saw similar failures.

   Container crash loopService outage

   Trigger

   At 23:04 PDT the node running the only Boskos pod was drained to be replaced with a 1.13 node during the upgrade of the Prow clusters from Kubernetes 1.11 to 1.13. The replacement pod started from the StatefulSet's current spec, which named a newer Boskos image containing the bug.

   Root cause

   Faulty deployment

   Component

   CI systemNode pool

   Contributing factor

   Change with a delayed effectUnverified assumptionSingle point of failureNo alert on limitChange started before off-hours

   Detection

   Users reported the failure on GitHub at 02:50 and on Slack at 05:16 and 06:27, and an engineer saw the Slack reports on waking at 07:16. The Boskos monitoring dashboard showed the failure, but no alert caught it.

   Remediation

   • Built and deployed a new Boskos image with the bug fixed
   • Cleaned up the GCP projects that had been left open

   Action items

   • Change the Boskos configuration so that deployments actually take effect (#11956)
   • Automate Boskos deploys (#11957)
   • Improve alerting on Boskos status (#11953)

   Lessons

   The write-up lists what went poorly: a ten-hour upgrade was started shortly after 17:00 when on-call coverage ended at 18:00; deployments were not checked to confirm that something had actually rolled out; the Boskos StatefulSet was not set up to perform updates, so changing its spec left the old pod running; the December change appears never to have been tested; and Boskos was deployed by hand, unlike most of Prow, which left more room for error. Once people were available, the problem was fixed quickly.

   View case

By root cause1