Cases62 cases

42 to 46 of 62

1. IL-0442 Older pods on LIFULL's KEEL Kubernetes cluster were preempted all at once and the external error rate spiked

   LIFULL2021

   Symptoms

   Shortly after the KEEL team applied new PriorityClasses to KEEL, LIFULL's Kubernetes cluster, and saw pods with the low class being preempted as intended, the team received a flood of alerts from external monitoring: the error rate of requests coming from outside the cluster had risen sharply.

   Pod evictionHigh error rate

   Trigger

   The KEEL team deployed three PriorityClasses to the running cluster: low with value: 100, medium with globalDefault: true and value: 1000, and high with value: 10000.

   Root cause

   Configuration change

   Component

   Pod priority and preemptionIngress controller

   Contributing factor

   Unverified assumption

   Detection

   External monitoring sent the team a large number of alerts about a sharp rise in the error rate of requests from outside the cluster.

   Action items

   • Redefine the PriorityClasses as low (-10), medium (0, globalDefault) and high (10), each with a non-preempting variant

   Lessons

   Adding PriorityClasses to a running cluster needs care because every existing pod has priority 0, and a globalDefault class above 0 makes all pods created before it candidates for preemption. PodDisruptionBudgets do not reliably protect pods from preemption. In a multi-tenant cluster, the permission to deploy PriorityClasses should be restricted, and the PriorityClasses tenants may use should be controlled with ResourceQuota or OPA Gatekeeper.

   View case
2. IL-0106 A malformed Traefik IngressRoute triggered a Traefik v2 bug once a node rollover restarted every Traefik pod, and all Kubernetes services returned 404

   DFDS2021

   Symptoms

   At 08:00 UTC on 2021-09-06 every service in DFDS's Kubernetes cluster answered with 404. Investigation started five minutes later.

   Service outageHigh error rateProbe failures

   Trigger

   The automated Kubernetes node rollover on 2021-09-06 restarted all the Traefik v2 pods, five days after a malformed IngressRoute manifest had been applied.

   Root cause

   Software defect

   Component

   Ingress controllerCloud load balancer

   Contributing factor

   Change with a delayed effectNo configuration testsExcessive blast radius

   Detection

   All services returned 404 from 08:00 UTC and root cause investigation started at 08:05. Time to detection was 5 minutes.

   Remediation

   • changed the ALB health check path, which made the targets healthy but did not stop the 404s
   • rolled back by hand to Traefik v1 as the main ingress controller
   • deleted the malformed IngressRoute by hand and confirmed the Traefik v2 bug
   • applied the changes upstream

   Action items

   • Upgrade Traefik to v2.5, where the bug is fixed, and verify that it removes the bug
   • Change the Traefik v2 health check path to something more robust
   • Set up an external liveness probe on the ingress controller
   • Consider workload segmentation to limit the blast zone
   • Look into monitoring the Traefik v2 API for rapid changes
   • Look into smoke testing during and after node rollover

   Lessons

   A malformed IngressRoute did nothing visible for five days and then took down all ingress when every Traefik v2 pod had restarted during a node rollover. Because Traefik v2 failed gracefully, the first signals pointed at the ALB health checks instead of at Traefik. On incident handling, the team concluded that appointing an incident manager could have helped, that the war room meeting should be recorded and a log book kept, that people not involved should only make suggestions in writing, and that a short first round of sharing thoughts and gut feelings is useful.

   View case
3. IL-0105 Replacing the AWS VPC CNI during a Terraform refactoring detached the ALB target groups, and every service in the Kubernetes cluster returned 503

   DFDS2021

   Symptoms

   At 08:29 UTC on 22 June 2021 alerts fired because all services in the Kubernetes cluster were returning 503. No inbound traffic was reaching the cluster. A customer reported the problem at 08:32.

   Service outageHigh error rate

   Trigger

   The pipeline replaced the AWS VPC CNI as part of a refactoring that moved EKS add-ons from kubectl to native Terraform management.

   Root cause

   Configuration change

   Component

   AWS VPC CNICloud load balancerTerraform

   Contributing factor

   Unverified assumptionNo configuration tests

   Detection

   Alerts fired at 08:29 UTC, eight minutes after the VPC CNI was replaced; a customer reported the issue at 08:32.

   Remediation

   • committed a fix that reverted the infrastructure-modules reference
   • re-triggered the pipeline after it failed on an AWS API timeout
   • let the pipeline reattach the target groups to the ALB

   Action items

   • Revert the ALB de-registration delay to the default of 300 seconds
   • Update the roll-over script to set the ALB de-registration delay to zero temporarily before a roll-over
   • Create an ingress test suite

   Lessons

   The change to the de-registration delay had been weighed mainly for performance. Critical pipeline runs should be watched while they run. Everyone should receive the alerts and react to them, and alert messages that were unclear should be reworded.

   View case
4. IL-0032 Mutating admission controller generated broken JSON patches, silently blocking deploys for a week until a production service ran down to two pods

   Airbnb2020

   Symptoms

   A production service at Airbnb showed a high error rate and could not be deployed. The deploy failed with a cryptic Kubernetes error about being unable to access invalid index 5.

   High error rateThroughput degradationDeploys failing

   Trigger

   A change to the mutating admission controller, which had been rolled out within the previous month, had gone in seven days before the incident surfaced; when it had to delete two items from an array in a spec, it generated an invalid JSON patch that removed index 2 and then index 3.

   Root cause

   Software defect

   Component

   Admission webhookHorizontal pod autoscaler

   Contributing factor

   Change with a delayed effectMonitoring blind spotIgnored early signal

   Detection

   The affected service reported a high error rate and its deploy failed; the slow degradation of other services over the previous seven days had gone unnoticed.

   Remediation

   • deleted the mutating admission controller from the affected cluster

   Action items

   • Create alerts from the existing metrics that would have shown the problem earlier

   Lessons

   Keep in mind that a mutating admission controller exists in the cluster; a recently added one is easy to forget during an incident. Search for the exact error message early instead of working on the visible symptoms. Page a teammate when progress stalls.

   View case
5. IL-0190 Cortex distributors kept a stuck connection to a dead etcd leader after a Kubernetes upgrade terminated its node, failing writes to Hosted Prometheus for 12 minutes

   Grafana Labs2020

   Symptoms

   About a minute after the etcd leader changed, two replicas of the Cortex distributor started logging "context deadline exceeded" when they tried to read keys from etcd. Writes from some customers that landed on those two replicas failed, while the other distributor replicas kept working, so the service saw an error rate of about 20% on writes to the London region of Hosted Prometheus.

   High error rateIntermittent timeouts

   Trigger

   A scheduled Kubernetes version upgrade abruptly terminated the node that ran the etcd leader at 11:19:00 UTC.

   Root cause

   Software defect

   Component

   etcdNode pool

   Contributing factor

   Unreviewed defaultsNo safeguard on destructive change

   Detection

   An SLO-based alert paged the on-call engineer at 11:31, 11 minutes after the errors started. At a 20% error rate the monthly SLA would have taken about 18 hours to breach.

   Remediation

   • Restarted the two affected Cortex distributor replicas at 11:32, which stopped the errors

   Action items

   • Enable gRPC keepalive probes in the Cortex etcd client (DialKeepAliveTime 10s, DialKeepAliveTimeout, PermitWithoutStream)
   • Make the Kubernetes upgrade process terminate pods and machines gracefully, including the etcd pods managed by the etcd operator

   Lessons

   When a node dies abruptly, clients holding TCP connections to it are not told; without keepalive probes an etcd client can keep sending requests into a dead connection long after a new leader exists. A failover that works on the server side still needs clients that detect the dead peer. Node replacement during cluster upgrades should drain pods gracefully, including pods owned by operators that the upgrade scripts do not know about, and should give instances enough time to shut down.

   View case

By root cause10