Cases15 cases

6 to 10 of 15

1. IL-0145 A power sag and chiller failure in one Australia East availability zone took down the AKS control plane's compute and its non-zone-redundant SQL Database operation queue, blocking AKS create, update and delete operations in Australia East and Australia Southeast

   Microsoft Azure2023

   Symptoms

   From about 10:30 UTC on 30 August 2023, customers had trouble accessing or using Azure, Microsoft 365 and Power Platform services in Australia East. The affected Azure services included Azure Kubernetes Service (AKS) along with storage, SQL Database, Cosmos DB, virtual machines and Azure Resource Manager.

   Control plane unresponsiveHigh error rateService outage

   Trigger

   At 08:41 UTC a lightning strike on electrical infrastructure about 18 miles away caused a utility voltage sag that shut down the cooling chillers of datacenters in one Australia East availability zone; 13 chillers failed to restart automatically and five could not be restarted, so two data halls overheated and their infrastructure was shut down.

   Root cause

   Cloud provider outage

   Component

   AKS control planeDatabase

   Contributing factor

   Single point of failureExcessive blast radius

   Detection

   Cosmos DB impact was detected by monitoring at 10:47 UTC, first automated communications went to Azure Service Health at 10:48 UTC, the public Azure Status page was updated at 11:30 UTC, and all subscriptions in Australia East were sent portal communications at 11:36 UTC.

   Remediation

   • shut down the remaining networking, compute and storage in the two affected data halls so the chilled water loop could cool down
   • restarted the five chillers manually at 12:12 UTC
   • restored power to all hardware by 15:10 UTC and brought infrastructure back in phases
   • restored AKS operations through the recovery of the SQL Database operation queue, with no other mitigation

   Action items

   • AKS: convert all operation queue SQL Database databases to be zone redundant (estimated September 2023)
   • AKS: replace all cross-region SQL Database queue usage with zone-redundant Service Bus queues (estimated September 2023)
   • Change the control timing logic of the Chiller Management System so chillers do not fail to restart after voltage fluctuations
   • Change the emergency procedure for manual restarts of simultaneous chiller failures from an adjacent sequence to a load-based sequence per data hall
   • Increase technician staffing at the datacenter as a temporary measure for manual chiller restarts
   • Storage: optimise the large-scale recovery process and update troubleshooting guides (estimated December 2023)
   • Azure Service Fabric: improve reliability of SQL Database tenant ring recovery (estimated December 2023)
   • SQL Database: review the trigger criteria of auto-failover groups (estimated October 2023)
   • SQL Database: upgrade internal tooling to enable mass migration of databases (estimated December 2023)
   • Cosmos DB: optimise Service Managed Failover for single-region-write accounts (estimated November 2023)
   • ARM: complete the migration of its storage layer to the zonally redundant architecture (estimated December 2023)
   • Incident management: harden readiness, process and playbook for power-down scenarios (estimated October 2023)

   Lessons

   A control plane spread across availability zones still fails with a zone when one of its dependencies, here the SQL Database operation queue, is not zone redundant. When a second region uses the same database, the failure crosses into that region as well. Workloads already running were not expected to be affected; what stopped was everything that needs the managed service's control plane, such as scaling and cluster changes.

   View case
2. IL-0096 A GKE node pool pinned to the europe-west2-b zone could not scale for 6.5 hours because Google ran out of resources in that zone (ZONE_RESOURCE_POOL_EXHAUSTED)

   2i2c2022

   Symptoms

   A user of the LIS JupyterHub reported a "backoff after failed scale-up" error, and user servers would not start. An engineer opened incident #36, "LIS hub cannot scale", at 5:40 AM Pacific on 14 November 2022.

   Scale-up failurePods PendingService outage

   Trigger

   At 10 AM UK time on 14 November 2022, the B zone of Google Cloud's europe-west2 region (London) ran out of resources to allocate. The LIS cluster's nodes were restricted to that zone.

   Root cause

   Cloud provider outage

   Component

   Node poolCluster autoscaler

   Contributing factor

   Single point of failurePages not delivered

   Detection

   A user reported the "backoff after failed scale-up" error; an engineer opened the incident at 5:40 AM Pacific, about three hours and forty minutes after the zone ran out of resources.

   Remediation

   • edited the node pool in the GCP console to allow node creation in the A and C zones of europe-west2, which were not exhausted

   Action items

   • Either restrict the node pool back to the B zone after the Black Friday event, or move the cluster and the NFS Filestore to the A zone (infrastructure issue #1944)
   • Investigate an enterprise plan that allows a regional NFS, at higher cost (infrastructure issue #1945)
   • Make sure PagerDuty notifications always get through to engineers (team-compass issue #574)

   Lessons

   A node pool pinned to one zone for storage performance cannot scale when the cloud provider runs out of capacity in that zone. The autoscaler's "backoff after failed scale-up" message usually points to quotas, and raising quotas does nothing here; the ZONE_RESOURCE_POOL_EXHAUSTED error in the logs is what identifies a zone without capacity. The review found that one engineer wearing many hats (incident commander, comms and debugging), with pages not reaching the other responders, made the response harder; a team response would have given more support.

   View case
3. IL-0514 PyPI's backends stopped responding for 7 minutes as rescheduled pods could not start while Consul and Vault were down

   Python Software Foundation2022

   Symptoms

   At 18:23 UTC on 28 July 2022, PSF Infrastructure got an alert that at least one Vault container in PyPI's Kubernetes cluster was down and needed unsealing. At 18:46 UTC PyPI's backends became unresponsive, and they stayed down until 18:53 UTC.

   Service outagePods stuck in Terminating

   Trigger

   From 17:24 UTC the cloud provider automatically replaced several instances of PyPI's Kubernetes cluster because of an unknown failure. All replacements were healthy by 18:20 UTC, but the event reshuffled many pods and restarted Consul and Vault on new nodes.

   Root cause

   Cloud provider outage

   Component

   Coordination and key-value storeSecrets store

   Contributing factor

   Automation amplification

   Detection

   An alert at 18:23 UTC told PSF Infrastructure that at least one Vault container was down and needed unsealing.

   Remediation

   • Forcefully removed the Consul pod stuck in Terminating so it was recreated and Consul could elect a leader
   • Unsealed the new Vault containers

   View case
4. IL-0364 A quarter of Cloud Platform ingress traffic was slow because an AWS NLB stopped health-checking targets in one zone

   UK Ministry of Justice2022

   Symptoms

   On 11 July 2022 users reported in the #ask-cloud-platform Slack channel that their applications on the Ministry of Justice Cloud Platform were slow some of the time. About 25% of ingress traffic was affected: after an AWS incident the day before, one of the three network interfaces of the 'default' ingress controllers performed slowly, and clients timed out when they tried to connect to one of the Elastic IPs of the Network Load Balancer (NLB) in front of them.

   High latencyIntermittent timeouts

   Trigger

   Some instances of the AWS NLB health checking subsystem were restarted, which set off a latent software race condition in that subsystem.

   Root cause

   Cloud provider outage

   Component

   Cloud load balancerIngress controller

   Contributing factor

   –

   Detection

   Users reported slow performance of their applications in the #ask-cloud-platform Slack channel.

   Remediation

   • AWS restarted the NLB health checking subsystem, which refreshed its list of targets and recovered the NLB in the affected Availability Zone

   Action items

   • Raised mitigation tickets after a post-incident review, filed as post-aws-incident issues in the ministryofjustice/cloud-platform repository

   View case
5. IL-0205 The GKE cluster autoscaler could not add nodes to GitLab.com's production cluster because Google Cloud ran out of SSD persistent disks in us-east1

   GitLab2021

   Symptoms

   At 08:05 UTC on 2021-06-21 the API service's Apdex (the share of requests that finish within a target time) and Rails request queuing began trending the wrong way. At 09:01 the team found the API deployment unhealthy: it needed more pods for the day's growing traffic, but no new nodes could be added to give it pod capacity. Users saw slow responses; the review found no sign that error rates rose.

   Scale-up failureHigh latencyPods PendingDeploys failing

   Trigger

   Google Cloud ran out of SSD persistent disk stock in us-east1, the region GitLab.com runs in, while the API service needed more nodes for rising user traffic.

   Root cause

   Cloud provider outage

   Component

   Cluster autoscalerNode pool

   Contributing factor

   Monitoring blind spotLimited debug accessOverlapping failures

   Detection

   There was no alert on resource availability. Apdex and Rails queuing began trending the wrong way at 08:05 UTC and an engineer declared the incident in Slack at 08:43; finding the cause took a lot of log digging: cluster autoscaler errors about node pools in backoff, then ZONE_RESOURCE_POOL_EXHAUSTED at the instance-group level, and finally Google Cloud support naming SSD as the exhausted resource.

   Remediation

   • added a node pool that uses pd-standard disks
   • scaled the new node pool by hand across all three zones to relieve the API
   • brought more pd-standard node pools online for the other blocked workloads
   • stopped production deployments and opened a Google Cloud support case about the cluster autoscaler not working with the new node pools
   • changed node pools and nodeSelectors so the remaining workloads ran on pd-standard nodes
   • removed the SSD-backed node pools after a day without problems

   Action items

   • Move Kubernetes services to pd-standard disks (delivery#1837)
   • Capture resource exhaustion errors as a metric

   Lessons

   A cloud region can run out of one specific resource, here SSD persistent disks, and the only error may be a generic ZONE_RESOURCE_POOL_EXHAUSTED that does not name it. GitLab could neither monitor nor reserve resource availability, so detection took 22 hours and the cause came from Google Cloud support. The workloads ran fine on pd-standard disks. A second problem found on the way, a cluster autoscaler that does not fall back to another matching node pool when one cannot scale, slowed the move to the new node pools.

   View case

By root cause1