Cases14 cases

9 to 13 of 14

1. IL-0203 A routine Kubernetes cluster system update made the AWS Load Balancer Controller fail, so new pods were never registered with the ALB and Honeycomb's EU1 ingest and UI went down once the last old pods were replaced

   Honeycomb2024

   Symptoms

   Event ingestion and the Honeycomb UI in EU1 became unavailable at 22:00:10 UTC on April 9, 2024, and the status page reported that the EU1 instance was down. Both the ingestion service and the service behind the web UI stopped at roughly the same moment.

   Service outageStale endpoint routing

   Trigger

   A routine system update to the Kubernetes cluster, rolled out earlier on April 9, followed by a regular deployment that replaced pods one at a time.

   Root cause

   Breaking change in an upgrade

   Component

   Ingress controllerCloud load balancer

   Contributing factor

   Monitoring blind spotUnrepresentative stagingChange with a delayed effect

   Detection

   The first status post, saying the EU1 instance was down, went up at 15:08 PDT (22:08 UTC), about 8 minutes after the outage began. There was no alerting on the AWS Load Balancer Controller.

   Remediation

   • Restarted the AWS Load Balancer Controller
   • Rolled back the Kubernetes cluster system update

   Action items

   • Find the exact cause of the failure so the system update can be deployed safely
   • Add monitoring and alerting on the AWS Load Balancer Controller so on-call engineers learn of a failure quickly and can pause deployments

   Lessons

   A rolling deployment can look healthy while the component that wires new pods into the load balancer is broken; the failure only shows when the last old pod goes away. Honeycomb now treats the AWS Load Balancer Controller as a critical component that needs its own alerting, so deployments can be paused before they remove the last pods that still receive traffic. Extensive testing in development and staging did not reveal the bad interaction.

   View case
2. IL-0180 A GKE control plane auto-upgrade from 1.22 to 1.23 removed the v1beta1 Ingress and ValidatingWebhookConfiguration APIs that Istio 1.7.4 still used, and Istio stopped working in production

   Sunwoo Park2023

   Symptoms

   On 2023-05-18 a Slack alert arrived at 20:01 and Istio stopped working properly in the production GKE cluster. The istiod error logs said that the v1beta1.Ingress and v1beta1.ValidatingWebhookConfiguration resources could not be found.

   Service outage

   Trigger

   GKE automatically upgraded the production cluster's control plane from 1.22.17-gke.7500 to 1.23.17-gke.1700 at 19:52 on 2023-05-18.

   Root cause

   Breaking change in an upgrade

   Component

   IstioGKE control planeAdmission webhook

   Contributing factor

   Deferred upgrades

   Detection

   A Slack alert at 20:01 on 2023-05-18, nine minutes after the control plane upgrade. The istiod error logs showed that the v1beta1 Ingress and ValidatingWebhookConfiguration resources could not be found.

   Remediation

   • upgraded Istio from 1.7.4 to 1.13.3

   Lessons

   The first diagnosis, end of support for Istio, was wrong; the real cause was found by matching the alert time against the cluster's UPGRADE_MASTER operations in Logs Explorer. The author recommends checking the version compatibility matrices of Kubernetes, Istio and other packages, keeping a production version for at least six months and upgrading three months before end of support, keeping the test environment on the latest version, backing up before upgrades, managing deployments and versions with a tool such as Argo CD, and testing upgrades in a test environment before production.

   View case
3. IL-0060 Kubernetes 1.24 upgrade removed the master node label that Calico route reflectors selected on, dropping all pod routes and taking Reddit down for 314 minutes

   Reddit2023

   Symptoms

   About two minutes after an engineer started the Kubernetes 1.23 to 1.24 upgrade of the cluster running Reddit's legacy stack, just after 19:00 UTC, the site stopped. The CDN edge request graph, which is kept separate from the cluster, showed traffic by status collapsing. Users saw the error page, a homepage with no posts, or plain errors.

   Service outageHigh error rateDNS resolution failuresMonitoring outagePods stuck in ContainerCreatingControl plane lag

   Trigger

   An in-place upgrade of the legacy cluster from Kubernetes 1.23 to 1.24; in 1.24 the node-role.kubernetes.io/master label is removed even from running clusters.

   Root cause

   Breaking change in an upgrade

   Component

   CalicoKubernetes API serverAdmission webhooketcd

   Contributing factor

   Configuration not in codeUnrepresentative stagingUntested backupMonitoring blind spotSingle point of failure

   Detection

   The site broke about two minutes into the upgrade; an incident was opened immediately and responders were on the call within three minutes, working from CDN edge graphs because the cluster's own metrics were gone.

   Remediation

   • deleted the Open Policy Agent webhook configurations to stop API server timeouts
   • terminated all worker nodes of the cluster
   • restored the control plane from the pre-upgrade backup onto the first control plane node
   • switched off the cluster autoscaler until the control plane was stable
   • generated new TLS certificates so replacement control plane nodes could join etcd
   • brought traffic back in steps from 1% to 100%
   • restarted legacy services that had been stopped by hand

   Action items

   • Codify cluster configuration so every choice has a record, and document in detail what cannot be codified
   • Standardise components across clusters and replace bespoke configurations
   • Build tooling to manage the lifecycle of whole clusters so they can be recreated or replicated
   • Add pre-production clusters that can be tested with confidence
   • Improve the backup restore process and make cluster upgrades safe

   Lessons

   Configuration that exists only in a live cluster, edited by hand through a special tool, can be forgotten, as the route reflector setup was, and then break on an upgrade nobody connects it to. A Kubernetes upgrade cannot be reverted without a restore, so the restore procedure has to be kept current and practised. Consistent, codified clusters are what make upgrades testable; bespoke clusters keep producing outages.

   View case
4. IL-0198 An automatic Ubuntu security update restarted systemd-networkd, which flushed the IP rules Cilium relied on and cut more than 60 percent of Datadog's Kubernetes nodes off the network across regions and cloud providers

   Datadog2023

   Symptoms

   Between 06:00 and 07:00 UTC on 8 March 2023, Kubernetes nodes in several Datadog regions lost network connectivity at the same time, on AWS, Google Cloud and Azure. All services across multiple regions were affected, including the regions that host Datadog's CI/CD and automation tools. Datadog's regions are not connected to each other and changes are rolled out one region at a time, so a simultaneous failure on several cloud providers looked implausible at first.

   Node NotReadyService outageThroughput degradation

   Trigger

   On 7 March 2023 Ubuntu published a systemd patch for a CVE (249.11-0ubuntu3.7). Ubuntu's default unattended upgrades installed it on the nodes between 06:00 and 07:00 UTC on 8 March, and installing it restarted systemd-networkd.

   Root cause

   Breaking change in an upgrade

   Component

   systemd-networkdCiliumNode operating system image

   Contributing factor

   Unreviewed defaultsChange with a delayed effectNo staged rolloutAutomation amplification

   Remediation

   • restarted thousands of disconnected instances on Google Cloud and Azure through the cloud APIs, keeping their local disks
   • rebuilt the data lost with terminated AWS instances' local disks through replication, reprocessing and restores from backup

   Lessons

   A change in a base operating system component can stay dormant for months until something restarts that component. Here the trigger was a security patch, and the change reached every region at once because automatic OS updates ran outside the progressive, region-by-region process used for every other change. Cloud providers react differently to an instance that loses its network. Google Cloud and Azure left the instances running, so a restart recovered them with their disks; AWS replaced them quickly, which brought stateless services back fast but destroyed the local-disk data the stateful services needed.

   View case
5. IL-0144 A systemd security update installed by unattended-upgrades lost the DNS configuration of Ubuntu 18.04 VMs, so AKS kubelets could not resolve registry names and pods failed with ImagePullBackOff

   Microsoft Azure2022

   Symptoms

   From 06:00 UTC on 30 August 2022, Azure VMs running Ubuntu 18.04 (bionic) with unattended-upgrades enabled began failing DNS resolution and losing network connectivity. Several Azure teams, among them the AKS and Azure Container Apps teams, were alerted by production alerts shortly after the update packages were published.

   DNS resolution failuresImage pull failuresMonitoring outage

   Trigger

   Unattended-upgrades on Ubuntu 18.04 VMs installed a Canonical security update published at 06:00 UTC on 30 August 2022, including systemd version 237-3ubuntu10.54.

   Root cause

   Breaking change in an upgrade

   Component

   Node operating system imagekubeletContainer registry and its credentialsClient-side DNS resolver and cache

   Contributing factor

   No staged rolloutExcessive blast radiusAutomation amplification

   Detection

   Several Azure teams, including AKS and Azure Container Apps, were alerted by production alerts shortly after the packages were published; incoming support cases then confirmed which Ubuntu versions were affected.

   Remediation

   • pointed customers to Canonical's description of the systemd bug and its fix
   • recommended rebooting affected VMs or running a template script that repairs DNS resolution
   • built automatic detection and remediation for AKS nodes and rolled it out across all regions
   • mitigated the remaining AKS customers manually through support

   Action items

   • Review the process that lets critical security updates bypass Safe Deployment Practices
   • Improve monitoring of the AKS data plane to alert on an uptick of errors
   • Review AKS monitoring algorithms so that similar VM errors are detected and alerted on
   • Establish an improved escalation path to Canonical during outages and add it to internal Technical Service Guides
   • AKS takes full control of the node security patch mechanism, with additional testing and controlled release of patches (estimated December 2022)
   • Work with Canonical to run dedicated tests on proposed packages before they are published for Azure IaaS VMs
   • Establish a process with Canonical to close the testing gap for the upgrade scenario (estimated March 2023)
   • Give AKS customers maintenance window control and environment staging for these patches (estimated December 2023)

   Lessons

   Security patches applied automatically by unattended-upgrades, once a day by default, and outside Azure's Safe Deployment Practices reached Ubuntu 18.04 VMs in every Azure region, so one systemd regression became a DNS outage across Azure. On AKS, lost node DNS showed up as image pull failures such as ImagePullBackoff, because kubelet could not resolve the registry. Azure plans to put node security patching under AKS's control with testing and controlled release; customers can use automatic node image upgrade for AKS, or automatic VM guest patching for VMs, instead of unattended-upgrades.

   View case

By root cause1