Cases33 cases

18 to 22 of 33

1. IL-0113 The managed GKE control plane of Webhook Relay's main cluster failed because its API server certificates had never been rotated, and a manual credential rotation reported success without taking effect

   Webhook Relay2022

   Symptoms

   At 12:00 EST the health check system reported that the backend APIs, the frontend and the tunnels in the EU region were down. The team first took it for a transient error, such as an interrupted client request or a server evicted for memory or CPU pressure, but the main dashboard was offline as well.

   Service outageControl plane lagControl plane unresponsiveStale or inconsistent API readsCredentials unavailable

   Root cause

   Certificate or credential expiry

   Component

   GKE control planeKubernetes API serverNode poolRBAC and service accounts

   Contributing factor

   Limited debug accessSingle point of failure

   Detection

   The health check system sent a notification that the service was down; the team then found the main dashboard offline.

   Remediation

   • recreated the node pools by hand after the credential rotation failed to recreate them
   • duplicated the main cluster's services into a newly created GKE cluster
   • deleted the Kubernetes Service records in the old cluster so its load balancers could be attached to the new cluster
   • detached the StatefulSet from the old cluster and switched all writes to the main disk
   • exported the data from the temporary ClickHouse instance and inserted it into the main instance

   Action items

   • Change the deployment manifests so services can be switched between clusters quickly without a complicated persistent disk migration

   Lessons

   Recovery of existing infrastructure needs a time limit. Throughout the outage the old cluster looked about to recover, and the reluctance to give up on the salvage effort kept the team from starting over with a new cluster much sooner, which would have been the right call. On older GKE clusters, check the validity of the cluster CA certificate, for example by decoding masterAuth.clusterCaCertificate from gcloud container clusters describe and reading it with openssl x509. GKE's multiple availability zones made no difference in this failure.

   View case
2. IL-0517 Gitpod workspaces failed to start worldwide and lost data when CoreDNS lookups to 8.8.8.8 timed out in its clusters

   Gitpod2022

   Symptoms

   At around 5.44pm UTC on 25 January 2022, Gitpod saw a high error rate when pulling images from Google Container Registry (gcr.io), with the error "cannot get manifest". About 10 minutes later users reported that they could not start workspaces.

   Image pull failuresDNS resolution failuresService outageData loss

   Root cause

   DNS or network fault

   Component

   CoreDNSContainer registry and its credentialsObject storage

   Contributing factor

   Single point of failure

   Detection

   The team noticed a high error rate on image pulls from GCR at around 5.44pm UTC; about 10 minutes later users reported that workspaces would not start, and the on-call team started incident response.

   Remediation

   • Created new workspace clusters in the EU and the US with a werft job
   • Redirected traffic to the new clusters

   Action items

   • Keep workspace data on cloud provider persistent volumes that survive node and cluster failures
   • Let users download their files from a workspace that cannot be started
   • Improve the workspace backup process
   • Use three DNS servers instead of one: a GCP-internal one, 8.8.8.8 and Cloudflare's 1.1.1.1
   • Do more DNS resiliency work, tracked in an epic
   • Improve support for multi-region clusters and later go multi-cloud

   View case
3. IL-0460 Vault served an expired TLS certificate and almost every GoCardless service pod crash-looped, a 22-minute full outage

   GoCardless2020

   Symptoms

   On Sunday 25 October 2020 the GoCardless API, dashboard, payment pages and partner integrations were all unavailable for 22 minutes, from 07:32 to 07:54 GMT. Automated monitoring paged the on-call engineer at 07:32, a minute after every request to the API had started failing because no healthy backend was left.

   Service outageContainer crash loopTLS certificate errorsCredentials unavailable

   Trigger

   At 07:22 the TLS certificate Vault was still serving expired. cert-manager had already renewed it, but Vault does not load a new certificate without a restart or a SIGHUP.

   Root cause

   Certificate or credential expiry

   Component

   cert-managerSecrets store

   Contributing factor

   Single point of failureMonitoring blind spotUnverified assumptionHarmful manual action

   Detection

   Automated monitoring detected the failing requests and paged the on-call engineer at 07:32. Certificate expiry monitoring existed for the Layer-7 load balancers but did not cover the TCP load balancer that Vault uses.

   Remediation

   • Forced cert-manager to recreate the Vault certificate
   • Restarted the Vault cluster by hand so it loaded the new certificate
   • Deleted some pods of critical workloads to skip their 5-minute exponential backoff

   Action items

   • Check the certificate of the TCP load balancer in front of Vault with the Blackbox exporter, as for the Layer-7 load balancers
   • Deploy the Reloader controller to roll Vault when its certificate data changes
   • Change theatre-envconsul so envconsul no longer manages the child process and only injects secrets at container startup

   Lessons

   A system that almost every service depends on, such as the secrets store, can take everything down at once, and failure scenarios like Vault becoming unreachable had not been tested enough. Assuming the certificate had expired, when it had been renewed but not reloaded, added a slow and unnecessary recreation step to the recovery.

   View case
4. IL-0088 A validating admission webhook added by a new ingress controller module version made the live-1 cluster reject every new Ingress with an x509 error

   UK Ministry of Justice2020

   Symptoms

   At 12:39 on 7 September 2020 the Cloud Platform team found that the Ingress API of the live-1 cluster was refusing every POST request. A user who provisioned a new service could not create an ingress into the cluster. The incident was declared at 12:54.

   Deploys failing

   Trigger

   Version 0.1.0 of the team's ingress controller module started creating a ValidatingWebhookConfiguration resource, and one new 0.1.0 ingress controller in the live-1 cluster failed to be created because of AWS resource limits.

   Root cause

   Faulty deployment

   Component

   Admission webhookIngress controller

   Contributing factor

   Single point of failure

   Detection

   The Ingress API was found refusing 100% of POST requests at 12:39; the incident was declared at 12:54.

   Remediation

   • removed by hand all the additional admission controllers created by module version 0.1.0
   • removed the admission webhook from the ingress controller module and released version 0.1.1
   • upgraded every ingress module on version 0.1.0 to 0.1.1

   Lessons

   Turning on the validating webhook in the shared ingress controller module made the webhook a single point of failure for every ingress controller pod in the ingress-controllers namespace: when one controller could not come up, no team could create an ingress.

   View case
5. IL-0093 Ingress controller pods crash-looped one after another because the leader pod had exhausted its shared memory

   UK Ministry of Justice2020

   Symptoms

   At 10:43 on 14 August 2020 two of the six ingress controller pods in the cluster were in a crash loop. Restarting those pods did not fix them.

   Container crash loop

   Root cause

   Capacity exhaustion

   Component

   Ingress controller

   Contributing factor

   Harmful manual actionSingle point of failure

   Detection

   Two of the six ingress controller pods were seen crash-looping at 10:43; the incident was declared at 11:01.

   Remediation

   • restarted the leader ingress controller pod so the other replicas could connect and get the latest nginx configuration

   View case

By root cause11