Cases2 cases

1 to 2 of 2

1. IL-0223 A connection surge congested the devices between AWS's internal and main networks in us-east-1, breaking EC2 APIs

   Amazon Web Services2021

   Symptoms

   From 7:30 AM PST on 7 December 2021, AWS services in us-east-1 that communicate between AWS's internal network and its main network saw rising latency and errors. The AWS operations teams lost real-time monitoring data at once, and the first thing found in the logs was elevated internal DNS errors.

   Control plane lagHigh latencyHigh error rateMonitoring outageDNS resolution failures

   Trigger

   At 7:30 AM PST an automated activity that scales the capacity of one AWS service hosted in the main AWS network triggered unexpected behaviour from a large number of clients inside the internal network.

   Root cause

   Software defect

   Component

   Transit gateway or network interconnectAutomated capacity manager

   Contributing factor

   Retry stormCircular dependency

   Detection

   The congestion immediately cut off real-time monitoring data for the AWS operations teams, who turned to logs and first identified elevated internal DNS errors.

   Remediation

   • Moved internal DNS traffic away from the congested network paths
   • Isolated the top sources of traffic onto dedicated network devices
   • Disabled some heavy network traffic services, including EventBridge event delivery
   • Brought additional networking capacity online
   • Disabled the automated scaling activities that triggered the event

   Action items

   • Keep the triggering scaling activities off until all remediations are deployed
   • Fix the latent issue that kept networking clients from backing off
   • Deploy network configuration that protects the affected networking devices in a similar congestion event
   • Keep API Gateway servers healthy when the internal network is unavailable and speed up their recycling
   • Release a new Service Health Dashboard that makes service impact easier to understand
   • Run the support system actively across multiple AWS regions

   View case
2. IL-0220 An overloaded AWS Transit Gateway dropped packets on 4 January 2021, and Slack's web tier saturated and went down

   Slack2021

   Symptoms

   During the Americas' morning of 4 January 2021, an external monitoring service paged Slack because error rates were creeping up. While the investigation was starting, Slack's own dashboarding and alerting service became unavailable, so responders had to work without their usual dashboards and alerts.

   High error rateMonitoring outagePacket lossService outageScale-up failureFile descriptor exhaustionCloud API rate limit exhausted

   Trigger

   On the first working day after the holidays, Slack's traffic went from the quietest time of the year to one of its biggest days overnight, with cold client caches pulling more data than usual, and one of Slack's AWS Transit Gateways did not scale fast enough for it.

   Root cause

   Cloud provider outage

   Component

   Transit gateway or network interconnectAutomated capacity manager

   Contributing factor

   Circular dependencyAutomation amplification

   Detection

   An external monitoring service paged Slack when error rates started creeping up during the Americas' morning. AWS engineers were separately alerted to the packet drops by AWS's internal monitoring.

   Remediation

   • Disabled automated downscaling of the web tier to keep serving capacity and allow investigation
   • Cleared up the broken, partly provisioned instances that filled the autoscaling groups
   • Repaired provision-service so new web tier instances could be provisioned and enter service
   • AWS engineers increased the Transit Gateway capacity manually across all Availability Zones

   Action items

   • AWS reviews its Transit Gateway scaling algorithms for large packet-per-second increases
   • Request a preemptive upscaling of the Transit Gateways at the end of the next holiday season
   • Run the dashboard service instances in the same VPC as their database to remove the Transit Gateway dependency
   • Load test provision-service regularly
   • Reevaluate health-checking and autoscaling configurations so they cannot overload provision-service again

   Lessons

   Monitoring has to stay as independent as possible of the infrastructure it watches, or it fails when it is needed most. Here the dashboard and alerting services failed because they ran in a different VPC from their databases and so depended on the Transit Gateways. provision-service had been load tested before, but this event exceeded the earlier scale-ups.

   View case

By root cause2