Cases3 cases

1 to 3 of 3

1. IL-0324 Three MediaWiki deployments lost Memcached after a PHP 8.1 rollout and overloaded the External Storage database cluster

   Wikimedia Foundation2025

   Symptoms

   On 2025-03-12 from 10:58 UTC, alerts for high backend response times came in, and the MediaWiki deployments mw-api-int, mw-parsoid and mw-jobrunner, which serve MediaWiki for non-user-facing purposes, showed high latency and database errors. The External Storage cluster, whose hosts store the compressed text of wiki page revisions, had a sharp rise in load and connections. The same happened again on 2025-03-13 from 11:15 UTC.

   Database overloadHigh latencyHigh error rateLog floodMonitoring outage

   Trigger

   At 10:44 UTC on 12 March a Scap deployment of the PHP 8.1 rollout for mw-api-int, mw-parsoid and mw-jobrunner was run with the flag -Dbuild_mw_container_image:False; the rollout was deployed with Scap again at 11:15 UTC on 13 March.

   Root cause

   Faulty deployment

   Component

   DatabaseIn-memory cacheConfigMaps and SecretsHelmCI system

   Contributing factor

   Unverified assumptionDependence on a warm cacheSignal buried in noise

   Detection

   Alerts for high backend response times started at 10:58 UTC on 12 March, 14 minutes after the Scap deployment; 2 on-call engineers were paged. The MediaWikiMemcachedHighErrorRate alert that pointed at the cause fired only briefly because its log pipeline was overloaded.

   Remediation

   • Deployed a patch to cirrus-streaming-updater that reduced SUP parallelism
   • Reduced the concurrency of the categoryMembershipChange job in changeprop-jobqueue
   • On 12 March, reverted 1126607 and 1126650 and re-ran Scap
   • On 13 March, rolling-restarted changeprop-jobqueue
   • Rolling-restarted mw-api-int
   • Disabled the categorymembership job in changeprop-jobqueue
   • Reverted 1127476 and 1127478
   • Redeployed mw-api-int to pick up the revert
   • Increased the number of mw-api-int replicas
   • Redeployed mw-jobrunner to pick up the revert
   • Redeployed mw-parsoid to pick up the revert

   Action items

   • Reduce the number of messages sent through channel:Memcached during failures
   • Add helm rollback functionality to Scap
   • Decide whether Scap should update helmfile-defaults when -Dbuild_mw_container_image:False is set
   • Consider removing envvars.inc from MediaWiki images
   • Consider "Why" dashboards that give an overview of a group of related components together with relevant links to follow
   • Coordinate incident responders better
   • Be able to work with MediaWiki developers during incidents

   Lessons

   The write-up puts the weight not on the technical root cause but on why the team could not see, even after the 12 March incident, that three MediaWiki deployments were running without Memcached. Alert dashboards showed what was happening, such as many busy PHP workers, but not why; dashboards linking components that affect each other, such as SQLBlobStore keys and External Storage, would have helped. The alert that pointed in the right direction did not stay firing and would probably have been lost among 78 others. The incident coordinator could not tell who was working on what or who had joined or left, the channels were noisy, the external impact was judged more critical than it was, and trace.wikimedia.org was not used although it might have helped.

   View case
2. IL-0571 STORES reservation returned bursts of 504 errors when a smart-list query held a database process for over 20 minutes

   STORES2024

   Symptoms

   About 20 minutes into a batch that rewrote the preset smart-list data of STORES 予約 (STORES reservation), an alert fired for a sudden rise in 504 errors (Gateway Timeout). The work had started a little after 03:00 UTC, and the metrics watched during it, such as web server response latency and the load of the writer database, had shown no large change.

   High error rateDatabase overload

   Trigger

   The preset smart lists 初回予約の顧客 (first-reservation customers) and 要フォロー顧客 (customers needing follow-up), created more than a month earlier, were rewritten with new search parameters after the search specification changed, which switched them onto the new search query.

   Root cause

   Faulty deployment

   Component

   Database

   Contributing factor

   Inefficient queryChange with a delayed effectUnrepresentative stagingMonitoring blind spotUnverified assumption

   Detection

   An alert on a sudden increase in 504 errors (Gateway Timeout), about 20 minutes after the preset rewrite batch started.

   Action items

   • Rework the database design so the inline-view search logic is no longer used
   • Add a test that checks this API's EXPLAIN output for scans larger than expected
   • Provide an environment where the timing of this logic can be measured easily

   Lessons

   Rushing to meet the schedule led to both a failure that affected users and a later release. In a multi-tenant database an EXPLAIN that shows index use can still hide large scans, tests need the case where one query is fast and the next is slow, the metrics to watch during a data change are those of the instance that serves the affected queries, and metrics sent at the end of a request are lost for requests that never finish.

   View case
3. IL-0566 Hot ranges after a Cookie Run: Kingdom guild update drove CockroachDB nodes to 100% CPU, forcing emergency maintenance

   Devsisters2021

   Symptoms

   About half an hour after the Cookie Run: Kingdom guild update maintenance ended at 11:00 on 6 March 2021, one CockroachDB node was using all 24 cores of its 24-core machine and server metrics began to show a significant number of errors. Soon two more nodes showed abnormal CPU use.

   Load imbalanceDatabase overloadHigh error rate

   Trigger

   During the guild update maintenance, new guild tables were added and pre-split across the cluster, and a new database node was added to replace one removed a few days earlier for a physical hardware issue. When the game reopened, all players at once wrote to existing tables whose primary-key prefixes were new or had changed in the update.

   Root cause

   Faulty deployment

   Component

   Database

   Contributing factor

   Unverified assumptionOverlapping failures

   Detection

   Monitoring after the maintenance showed one node's CPU at the ceiling together with errors in server metrics. Later a Slack alert reported a node failing its Host Status Check, and the abnormal-log channel reported filemap_fdatawait_range_keep_errors.

   Remediation

   • Blocked new logins without kicking players already in the game, using the maintenance switch as a makeshift access queue
   • Put the game into full emergency maintenance at 14:50 when several nodes failed health checks
   • Backed up the game data table by table after the full database backup stalled
   • Paused writing play records to reduce load on the database before reopening
   • Split the problem tables from about 18:30
   • Decommissioned the node that failed its Host Status Check
   • Reopened the game and used the login-block queue again when a node reached 100% CPU
   • Terminated the node that kept returning to 100% CPU

   Lessons

   In a single-server relational database a change to the primary-key prefix is usually harmless, but in CockroachDB's distributed design such a change on a production cluster needs great care. The team had studied this in CockroachDB documentation, but living through it taught far more than reading about it.

   View case

By root cause1