Cases3 cases

1 to 3 of 3

1. IL-0085 A control plane node of Magic Pages' Kubernetes cluster on Hetzner Cloud ran out of memory, the cluster's own calls then used up the Hetzner API rate limit, and all customer websites were down for about 7.5 hours

   Magic Pages2025

   Symptoms

   At around 09:33 UTC one of the three control plane nodes of the Kubernetes cluster that hosts Magic Pages went offline. Looking at the node showed that it had run out of memory.

   Service outageNode NotReadyCloud API rate limit exhausted

   Trigger

   One of the three control plane nodes ran out of memory and went offline at about 09:33 UTC; the attempts to replace it with hetzner-k3s failed while the cluster's own components were exhausting the Hetzner API rate limit.

   Root cause

   Capacity exhaustion

   Component

   Cloud controller managerPersistent volumes and stateful sets

   Contributing factor

   Unknown limitRetry stormMonitoring blind spotLimited debug accessSingle point of failureNo runbook

   Detection

   The founder found the control plane node offline at about 09:33 UTC. Monitoring alerts about unreachable customer websites started around the time the replacement attempts failed, and about half an hour of investigation identified the exhausted Hetzner API rate limit.

   Remediation

   • powered off all servers of the Kubernetes cluster to stop the API requests so the Hetzner rate limit could recover
   • waited until ratelimit-remaining had built up a buffer before starting recovery
   • restarted the control plane servers
   • started the essential Longhorn components by hand so Longhorn could heal and make storage volumes available
   • restarted the remaining websites by hand

   Action items

   • Monitor the Hetzner API call rate coming from the Kubernetes cluster nodes themselves to get early warning of high usage
   • Get a higher Hetzner API rate limit; Hetzner support was contacted
   • Investigate how to reduce the cluster's reliance on a single API, including alternatives to hetzner-k3s
   • Document and test a procedure for recovering Longhorn after a full cluster shutdown

   Lessons

   The running cluster, not only the deployment tooling, consumed the cloud provider's API quota, and in a failure it consumed it fast enough that the quota never recovered. The default limit of 3600 requests per hour was not enough for failure and recovery scenarios, and API usage from inside the cluster was not monitored. A tool that hides the provider's API errors slows diagnosis. After a full, non-graceful shutdown, Longhorn needed manual intervention to come back, which lengthened the outage.

   View case
2. IL-0168 Simultaneous cluster auto-upgrades overloaded Scaleway's Kubernetes API, and a node authentication retry loop kept Kapsule and Kosmos nodes NotReady in FR-PAR

   Scaleway2024

   Symptoms

   At 01:04 CET on 13 February 2024, the Kubernetes API behind Scaleway's managed Kubernetes services Kapsule and Kosmos in the Paris region (FR-PAR) spiked in RAM and CPU use and ran out of memory. Nodes in FR-PAR could no longer authenticate to their control plane, and some of them went "Not Ready". Customers on both shared (mutualized) and dedicated environments were affected.

   Node NotReadyControl plane lagOOMKilled

   Trigger

   A new Kubernetes release was made available to all users on 12 February 2024, and during the night of 12 to 13 February many clusters triggered their auto-upgrade at the same time.

   Root cause

   Capacity exhaustion

   Component

   Kubernetes API server

   Contributing factor

   Retry stormAutomation amplificationNo staged rollout

   Detection

   The timeline's first entry, at 01:04 CET, records the Kubernetes API's RAM and CPU spikes and out-of-memory state, with nodes unable to authenticate to their control plane and some becoming "Not Ready". The first recorded action, 42 minutes later at 01:46, was to increase the resources allocated to the API.

   Remediation

   • increased the resources allocated to the Kubernetes API at 01:46 and again at 02:20
   • applied API traffic restrictions at 02:30 to smooth the incoming traffic
   • removed the traffic restrictions progressively in 50-100 batches from 03:20
   • ran a script at 03:40 to replace the failing nodes created during the congestion
   • rolled back to the former node authentication mechanism, first on a subset of clusters from 15:45 and on all clusters by 19:41 on 19 February
   • disabled cluster upgrade and configuration update features until 10:30 on 20 February

   Action items

   • Increase the resources allocated to the Kubernetes API
   • Roll back to the former node authentication mechanism
   • Implement a local authentication cache on nodes
   • Rework the resource allocation strategy to behave better under load spikes
   • Add new request queuing mechanisms for Kubernetes
   • Separate the different components to reduce side effects under high load or failure
   • Monitor selected metrics closely to identify anomalous patterns earlier
   • Refund customers who deployed nodes during the incident but could not use them normally

   Lessons

   Letting many clusters auto-upgrade at the same moment after a release turns routine upgrades into one coordinated load spike on the shared Kubernetes API. A node authentication mechanism that retries without letting up turns a slow API into an unavailable one, and auto-healing that replaces NotReady nodes amplifies the problem. The congestion pattern had already appeared three weeks earlier, and short-term mitigations did not stop it from recurring, so Scaleway rolled back the new authentication mechanism. Scaleway notes that as the number of customer clusters and nodes grows sharply, traffic control mechanisms have to improve to prevent congestion.

   View case
3. IL-0169 The Scaleway Kubernetes API in FR-PAR ran out of memory under simultaneous deployments, and because it also handled node authentication, Kapsule and Kosmos nodes went NotReady

   Scaleway2024

   Symptoms

   At 23:48 CET on 24 January 2024 the Scaleway Kubernetes API for the FR-PAR region ran out of memory. At the same minute Scaleway saw requests to its API Gateway spike.

   Node NotReadyOOMKilledIntermittent timeoutsMonitoring outage

   Trigger

   Simultaneous deployments in the FR-PAR region pushed the Scaleway Kubernetes API out of memory.

   Root cause

   Capacity exhaustion

   Component

   Container memory limitkubelet

   Contributing factor

   Single point of failureRetry storm

   Detection

   Increased load on the API Gateway was detected at 23:48, the minute the incident began, and the incident was escalated to on-call engineers at 00:00:10.

   Remediation

   • raised the memory limit and garbage collection thresholds of the Kubernetes managed services
   • deployed additional replicas of key services
   • purged the registry cache and monitored the clusters as they stabilised
   • adjusted service configurations after the incident to keep the platform stable

   Action items

   • Implement a local authentication cache
   • Further develop node authentication
   • Enhance monitoring, adjust rate limiting strategies and improve incident response protocols

   Lessons

   Because the Kubernetes API also handled node authentication, its memory exhaustion made some nodes NotReady, and the endless retries of those nodes added load on the API Gateway. Scaleway plans a local authentication cache and further work on node authentication.

   View case

By root cause1